Will a 25p charge change Britain's throwaway coffee cup culture? | Environment
On a busy Guildford high street reaction to the proposed 'latte levy' is mixed. While many welcome the move to change peoples' habits, for some, already feeling the squeeze of a weak pound, the 25p hit is too high
Will a 25p charge change Britain's throwaway coffee cup culture? | Environment
Turn any corner in the busy town centre of Guildford on a weekday morning, and someone is carrying a disposable cup bearing the logo of one of the major chains.
Each minute in the UK about 500 of these used coffee cups are thrown away. Every year consumers use and dispose of 2.5bn of them. The vast majority are not recycled.
On the main high street, coffee drinkers come and go, a few searching for the local authority "on the go" recycling bins in which to deposit their used vessel. Few are aware that their well meaning efforts will do little to reduce the waste mountain created by Britain's £9bn coffee-shop habit.
The UK has just three facilities that can split the paper and plastic components, which line the cardboard cups, for recycling. These facilities are not part of the general recycling system, and less than 1 in 400 cups – under 0.25% – are recycled.
To tackle the waste mountain, MPs have called for a 25p levy on takeaway coffees and teas to fund infrastructure in the next five year to make all cups recyclable. If this fails they say disposable cups should be banned.
Off the main high street in Guildford, the likes of Pret a Manger, Costa and Caffè Nero, are all busy with customers; young mothers, businessmen and women with laptops open, and students catching up on their reading.
Those served takeaway cups are often reassured by the recycling logo on the lid or the cup itself. Many of the customers said they believed the cups were widely recyclable.
Businesswoman Caroline Gangadeen, who runs a property and retail business in the Guildford area, bristled at the suggestion that consumers should be forced to pay a 25p charge on a cup, believing that the eight cups a day she purchases were all recyclable.
When she learned that most cups are not able to be recycled, Gangadeen said: "No one has told me any different and I think this needs to be properly communicated to people. I am still not happy to pay an extra 25p on top, as we pay enough for a coffee in the first place. But what it might make me do is remember to bring my own refillable cup more often."
Carrying a Costa disposable cup, Kate Roberts, said she would support a 25p charge. "It worked with the plastic bag charge," she said. "It would probably push me to finally get a reusable cup as I do try to be environmentally aware."
Leonie Schmidt, a student in the town, said: "I think it's a good way to start doing something about this. The ideal situation would be to find a cup that is recyclable or carry a reusable one."
But Will Gill, an independent retailer who runs a cafe up a cobbled street, says it will not be so easy to persuade consumers to fork out for a bespoke cup – and then take it everywhere with them.
Gill has been serving coffee for 13 years. Today he faces tough competition from all the major chains such as Starbucks, Costa and Caffè Nero, which each have three outlets in the Surrey town.
Now a David surrounded by Goliaths, Gill has tried to persuade those customers who buy takeaways to use environmentally friendly biodegradable bamboo cups. A sign in his store offers a free coffee if customers purchase the Ecoffee cup for £9.99.
"We do try, but the uptake is small and it is quite a cost to me," said Gill. As an independent retailer he does not have the purchase power of the giant coffee chains to get his bamboo cups any cheaper than £6 each from the niche supplier. Add on the free coffee and Gill says he is barely breaking even.
Instead most of his takeaway customers are served in normal disposable cups.
"Arguably there is probably the technology out there to make a properly recyclable cup," said Gill. "But like a lot of things in life, we need the big chains; the Costas and Starbucks, to be going down that road to forge the path for independent cafes, because it is hard for me to do it alone."
With rising business rates, the minimum wage payments for his staff, and the price of coffee up 30% since Brexit as the pound drops against the dollar, the prospect of adding 25p on top of the price of a cup of coffee for his customers is something he does not entirely welcome.
If a charge is necessary to change public behaviour, it should be 10p, closer to the 5p on plastic bags, he said.
"Ultimately it would be much better if people walked in with their own cup," he said. "If you think about how people bring their own bags to the shops now since the plastic bag charge, it is similar. But while going shopping is something you plan, buying a coffee is often spontaneous and people don't always have their cup with them."
Which reusable cup to buy?
As disposable coffee cups follow the likes of plastic bottles, diesel cars and sweatshop clothing into the realm of frowned-upon consumer goods, a sudden flurry of reusable alternatives are catching the eye.
Consumers can pay anything from £4 to more than £30 for an almost limitless range of products in glass, plastic and even biodegradable materials.
The five we have chosen (but not tested) are among the more environmentally friendly.
Bamboo cup from Surfers Against Sewage: created from bamboo, free from petrochemical plastic. Retails at £12 - dishwasher proof.
Keep Cup
Keep cup: Started by a couple in Melbourne. Plastic but they say less plastic. And washable and reusable. They say there is enough plastic in 28 disposable cups to make one small KeepCup. Customisable. Retails at £10
Ecoffee bamboo cup: Retails at £9.99. Plastic free and dishwasher proof.
Stojo: Like the idea, but don't think it would fit in your bag? Try the collapsible range from this company founded by three New York dads who claim to have produced "the world's first ultra-portable, leak-proof reusable cup". From about £12.
Rice Way reusable coffee cup
Rice Way: For the ultimate in reusable, recycled and biodegradable, how about a vessel made of rice husk. Manufacturers of the Rice Way range say it is 100% organic, lasts for years, is microwavable – but is biodegradable too. It will set you back at least £18 though.
